Skip to content
★ Hand-built in San Antonio, Texas — since 1999 ★
HVACWeb Designer

The Dispatch · Filed November 10, 2026 · 3 minute read · By Casey Kinnison

The Ledger —

“Website” Is Not a Marketing Channel

If your campaign report credits half of last year’s revenue to “Website” and “Google,” it isn’t reporting. It’s shrugging with a pie chart. Here is where the data leaks, in order.

Vintage illustration of a plumber with a wrench and a pie chart looking up at a copper pipe leaking from several tagged holes

Ask most shops where last year’s revenue came from and the report will answer with great confidence: “Website.” Also “Google,” and “Existing customer.” This is the same as asking a witness who robbed the bank and being told “a person.” It is technically true, and you still cannot do anything with it.

The field software is rarely the problem. ServiceTitan has every field needed to trace a dollar from first click to paid invoice. It simply cannot report what it was never told. The mush comes from upstream, and it comes from four specific places. Fix them in this order, because each one depends on the last.

Leak one: the form that forgets

A visitor clicks an ad, reads three pages, and fills out a form. The ad platform knows where they came from. The form, in most contractor sites, does not: it emails a name and a phone number to the office, and the trail ends there. The fix is unglamorous. The website records the source on arrival, holds onto it across pages, and passes it along with the booking so it lands on the job.

Leak two: the untracked phone

For most contractors, the phone is still where the majority of jobs are booked. If every visitor sees the same number, then every call looks the same, and whatever you learned in leak one stops at the part of the business that matters. Tracked numbers matched to campaigns tag the call before anyone says hello.

Leak three: the dropdown

Here is a scene from any office in America. A CSR with two calls on hold reaches the campaign field and picks the first thing on the list. No one trained them to lie; the system asked a busy person a question whose answer they do not know. Any attribution that depends on a human remembering to ask “how did you hear about us?” and believing the reply is a survey, not a measurement. Let the campaign arrive on the job automatically, and name the campaigns in ServiceTitan the same way they are named in the ad account, so the two reports can be read side by side.

“Every ad budget has a wasted half. Attribution is how you learn which half it is.”

Leak four: the ad platform never hears how it ended

This is the leak that costs real money, and almost nobody plugs it. Left alone, Google Ads optimizes for what it can see: clicks and form fills. It has no idea that one campaign’s calls turned into $12,000 systems and another’s turned into people asking if you service window units. So it cheerfully buys more of whichever is cheapest.

Google lets you report back. Its current recommendation for new setups is enhanced conversions for leads, which matches the sale to the original lead using first-party data such as a hashed email address, without changing your forms to store a click ID. The older click-ID import still exists but Google now treats it as a legacy approach. Whichever route fits, the principle holds: send the sold job and its value back, and the platform starts bidding toward people who pay. Meta offers a similar arrangement.

What you get for the trouble

  • A cost per booked job by channel, calculated instead of guessed. The cost-per-job calculator shows the math.
  • The ability to cut the campaign that makes the phone ring with the wrong calls.
  • The nerve to fund the unglamorous one that quietly fills the replacement calendar.
  • Marketing meetings that end early, because the argument has been replaced with a number.

Source capture starts working the day it launches. Return figures need a full sales cycle behind them before you trust them: a few weeks for repair, longer for replacements. The work itself is laid out under ServiceTitan marketing attribution, and it pairs naturally with running the ads themselves. Start with leak one. The pie chart will not fix itself, but it will get a great deal more interesting.

CK

Filed by Casey Kinnison
Building websites for the trades since 1999. San Antonio, Texas.

Don’t sweat it —

The Dispatch is free. The machine is quoted.

If a filing hit close to home, the fix is one phone call away — fixed price, real date, same writer.

One craftsman · One promise · 7–10 days to launch